SEO is often viewed as a results-driven discipline, with rankings, traffic, and leads being the ultimate measures of success. But what many don’t talk about is how failure plays a significant role in the journey.
Recently, SEO professional Shanta Narang shared a refreshingly honest post on LinkedIn that resonates deeply with marketers, business owners, and SEO specialists alike. She reminded us that even after years of experience, not every strategy hits the mark—and that’s okay.
The Reality of SEO: No Guarantees, Only Hypotheses
In her post, Shanta reflects on a recent attempt where she applied a widely accepted SEO strategy—one that has worked well for others—but saw no positive outcome in her own project. After giving it a fair shot, she made the smart move to drop it and pivot. Her takeaway? “Don’t be afraid to experiment.”
This message holds a powerful truth: SEO is not a fixed formula. What works for one website may flop for another. Every niche, domain, audience, and search behavior is different. And while we can use data, tools, and experience to guide us, there’s always a layer of uncertainty.
Why SEO Fails—And Why That’s Okay
Here are a few reasons even seasoned professionals may face SEO failure:
- Google’s algorithm is always evolving.
- User behavior shifts over time.
- Competitor strategies can interfere.
- Technical or UX issues can bottleneck efforts.
- Some niches are just harder to rank in.
But failure in SEO isn’t the end—it’s data. Every failed attempt adds to your understanding of what doesn’t work for your site or audience. As Shanta mentioned, “even failures can teach you something.”
Learning from the Process, Not Just the Results
The SEO community often celebrates success stories—those massive traffic gains or page 1 rankings—but not enough people talk about the trials that didn’t go anywhere. Shanta’s transparency is a much-needed reminder that the process matters just as much as the outcome.
If your strategy didn’t yield results, ask:
- Did it fail because of poor execution or poor fit?
- Were external factors like competition or seasonality involved?
- What can be tweaked and tested differently next time?
Document, reflect, and iterate. That’s how you grow in SEO.
The Courage to Experiment
One of the hardest things in digital marketing is letting go of what “should work.” It takes courage to walk away from a proven tactic when it doesn’t serve your unique case. But experimentation is the soul of SEO.
From A/B testing meta tags to reworking content clusters to changing your backlink approach—you never truly know until you try.
And Yes, SEO Is Still Alive
In another recent post, Shanta addressed a common myth: that “SEO is dead.” Her reply?
“SEO is not dead; it’s just changing and growing.”
She’s absolutely right. SEO is evolving fast—and those who learn, adapt, and experiment are the ones who’ll continue to thrive.
Closing Thoughts: Stay Curious, Stay Motivated
SEO isn’t a race. It’s a long-term, constantly evolving discipline. You’ll win some, and you’ll lose some. But every campaign, win or lose, adds to your expertise.
Kudos to professionals like Shanta Narang who share not just their victories, but their honest missteps too. It reminds us all that the best SEOs aren’t the ones with the flashiest results—but the ones who stay curious, keep experimenting, and never stop learning.
If you’d like to follow Shanta for more real-world SEO insights, connect with her here:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/seowithshanta/
Author’s Note:
This blog was inspired by two recent LinkedIn posts by Shanta Narang. If you’re in SEO or digital marketing, follow her for grounded, insightful, and real-world SEO perspectives.
Leave a comment